The Real Beautiful Game: Soccer, Migration, and the Messy Legacy of Colonialism

Ah, soccer—a sport where one minute you’re celebrating a homegrown hero, and the next, realizing that “homegrown” might mean something else entirely. Soccer (or football, depending on which side of the Atlantic you're on) is much more than a game; it’s a complex web of migration, identity, and the unshakeable remnants of colonial history.

Colonialism and the Spread of Soccer

To understand why soccer today is such a melting pot, let’s take a quick look at colonialism. Europeans spread their influence—and soccer—far and wide, with the sport finding a welcome home in South America, Africa, and Asia. What began as a game played by British soldiers quickly grew roots among colonized populations, who used it to assert their identities, ironically, against the very nations that “gifted” them the game.

Fast-forward a century, and post-colonial countries not only continued playing soccer but began producing some of the world’s best talent. That’s when former colonial powers realized their former colonies were brimming with players who could add a bit of fire to their own national teams. Naturally, they started scouting and integrating these players into their clubs and even their national teams, leading to today’s often blurry definitions of “home” in soccer.

The Tug of War Over Talent

Take the example of France, a team historically stacked with players of African descent. These players didn’t just get there on a whim; they’re descendants of immigrants who arrived from former colonies, carrying a dream for a better life—and, incidentally, an incredible ability to dribble. From Zidane (of Algerian descent) to Kylian Mbappé (with roots in Cameroon and Algeria), France’s World Cup wins are a testament to the country’s colonial past—whether they admit it or not.

England and the Netherlands have similar stories. Meanwhile, Japan is catching on, with Brazilians of Japanese descent (like Rui Ramos) paving the way for multicultural representation in Japanese soccer. In some cases, players hold dual citizenship and face the ultimate question: which country to represent?

And then there’s the “great divide”: club teams versus national teams. Club teams, largely driven by the highest bidder, become homes for talent from every corner of the globe, creating cosmopolitan powerhouses like FC Barcelona or Bayern Munich. They bring together players with nothing in common but the uniform, creating chemistry that feels more like a corporate merger than national pride. But ironically, these club teams arguably represent the “spirit of soccer” better than national teams do because they’re built purely on skill, not passports.

The Identity of a “National” Team: Blurred Lines

Let’s face it—the concept of a national team is increasingly open to interpretation. FIFA’s rules on player eligibility are complex, allowing athletes to choose countries based on ancestry, residency, or sometimes just paperwork. This has led to players representing nations they’ve barely set foot in, triggering debate over what a “national team” really stands for. Some argue this devalues the “purity” of international competition; others say it reflects a beautifully interconnected world. After all, isn’t soccer about bringing people together? Just maybe not in the way we expected.

Club Loyalty vs. National Pride: Who Represents the “True” Spirit of Soccer?

So, here’s the ultimate irony: club teams, motivated by wealth, may actually embody soccer’s core values better than national teams. Club teams mix players based on ability and chemistry alone, forming a sort of United Nations of talent. Meanwhile, national teams are seen as symbols of national pride, yet they’re filled with players whose ancestry, upbringing, and cultures are as varied as club lineups. National teams, despite their patriotic appeal, are beginning to look more and more like club teams in terms of player diversity—just with a flag slapped on.

In Japan, this discussion has taken on a unique flavor as the country embraces its own multiculturalism, especially with talents like Daniel Schmidt and Ko Itakura stepping up. What Japan’s experience shows is that national pride and diversity can indeed coexist, although the question remains: are we celebrating the national team’s talent or just its ability to select talent regardless of its origins?

Conclusion: A World Cup of Questions

Soccer, in all its glory, has outgrown borders, thanks to a messy history and a modern appetite for talent. National teams may still stir patriotic fervor, but club teams arguably represent a new, globalized ideal. So, next time you cheer for your team, whether national or club, remember: the beautiful game, much like the world itself, is a blend of cultures, histories, and contradictions.

【参考】
VEGEDREAM - RAMENEZ LA COUPE A LA MAISON https://youtu.be/RHb5LKnnxLg?si=pCuAXA3KjxDqwgyf
RADWIMPS『大団円 feat.ZORN』（Ｊリーグ30周年記念アンセム）　Ｊリーグ公式YouTubeチャンネル限定！オリジナルコンテンツ映...
https://youtu.be/K58aeHcTwWI?si=YHL_T9SAE7LlK3j5