Joker's Song of Love and Turmoil: Bewitched from Joker: Folie à Deux – Mindful Listening

1. One-Line Summary

• The song portrays the emotions of a protagonist who is bewitched and bewildered by love.

2. Basic Information

• Title: Bewitched

• Artists: Joaquin Phoenix & Lady Gaga

• Released: 2024 (from the Joker: Folie à Deux soundtrack)

3. Three-Line Summary

• The protagonist acknowledges being in love but feels bewildered by it.

• Despite knowing the other person's coldness, he cannot escape their charm.

• As a result, he oscillates between the joy and anguish of love.

4. What the Song Conveys

4.1. Main Claim

• The song expresses the complex psychology of a person who, despite understanding logically, is overwhelmed by emotions.

4.2. Supporting Evidence

• It is shown that the protagonist is aware of the other's flaws and his own foolishness, yet cannot escape his affection.

4.3. Three Examples

1. He is enchanted by her smile despite knowing her coldness.

2. He recognizes that he is acting like a child.

3. He spends sleepless nights because of love.

5. Context

5.1. Common Beliefs at the Time

• Love was often seen as something that could be controlled rationally.

• Showing vulnerability was frowned upon.

• Social status and responsibilities were valued over emotions.

5.2. Differences from Common Beliefs

• The protagonist is honest about his emotions.

• He openly expresses his vulnerability and confusion.

• He prioritizes personal feelings over social norms.

5.3. Related Thinkers Across Time

• William Shakespeare: Explored human emotions and their complexities.

• Fyodor Dostoevsky: Focused on deep psychological introspection.

• Edgar Allan Poe: Expressed the conflict between emotion and reason.

Why? These authors also delved into the complexities of human psychology and emotions.

5.4. Conflicting Thinkers Across Time

• Immanuel Kant: Emphasized rationality over emotions.

• Thomas Hobbes: Advocated for self-preservation above emotional indulgence.

• Stoic Philosophers: Argued for the suppression of emotions.

Why? These thinkers prioritized reason and self-control over emotional vulnerability.

5.5. Relevance Today

• The conflict between emotion and reason remains a universal theme.

• Many people still experience the confusion and turmoil of love.

• Expressing personal feelings is more accepted in today's society.

5.6. Originality

• The song poetically expresses the complexity of emotions.

• It portrays the protagonist's vulnerability in a positive light.

• It deeply explores the dual nature of love, balancing joy and suffering.

6. Learn from the Song